The COVID-19 pandemic raised questions about reconciling health priorities with the exercise of certain liberties and rights. Public safety has come into conflict with matters of mobility, freedom of expression, and the right to protest. How can the threat of viral transmission be reconciled with the urgency of political protests, such as in the Black Lives Matter movement? This article discusses various approaches, referring to debates in the United States and Australia, where law enforcement authorities and politicians warned against protest marches, generally citing the protection of public health as a qualifying exception. Numerous epidemiologists, while acknowledging risks, argued that a calculus of risk be deployed, citing public health as a variegated, multilayered concept. A similar balancing act was deployed in Australian courts. Such reasoning led to accusations that public health science had been politicized. Striking the balance remains a pragmatic approach to holding such gatherings during times of pandemic.
Binoy Kampmark is a senior lecturer in the School of Global, Urban and Social Studies, RMIT University, Melbourne. He was a Commonwealth Scholar at Selwyn College, University of Cambridge and is a contributing editor to CounterPunch. Email: email@example.com
Anthony, Thalia. 2020. “‘I Can't Breathe!’ Australia Must Look in the Mirror to See Our Own Deaths in Custody.” The Conversation, 2June. https://theconversation.com/i-cant-breathe-australia-must-look-in-the-mirror-to-see-our-own-deaths-in-custody-139848.)| false
Aspinwall, Nick. 2020. “The Philippines’ Coronavirus Lockdown is becoming a Crackdown.” The Diplomat, 3April. https://thediplomat.com/2020/04/the-philippines-coronavirus-lockdown-is-becoming-a-crackdown/.)| false
Aubrey, Allison, Isabella GomezSarmiento, and PranavBaskar. 2020. “Coronavirus FAQs: How to Stay Safe While Protesting, When to Go Out After Recovery.” Goats and Soda, National Public Radio, 5 June. https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/06/05/870306050/coronavirus-faqs-how-to-stay-safe-while-protesting-when-to-go-out-after-recovery.)| false
Bayer, Ronald. 2007. “The Continuing Tensions between Individual Rights and Public Health: Talking Point on Public Health versus Civil Liberties.” Embo Reports 8: 1099–1103.10.1038/sj.embor.7401134)| false
Berger, Matt. 2020. “Why the Black Lives Matter Protests Didn't Contribute to the COVID-19 Surge.” Healthline, 8July. https://www.healthline.com/health-news/black-lives-matter-protests-didnt-contribute-to-covid19-surge.)| false
Best, Jessica. 2020. “Everything You Need to Know about Sydney's Black Lives Matter Vigil Happening Today.” Urban List, 6June. https://www.theurbanlist.com/sydney/a-list/black-lives-matter-protest-sydney.)| false
Council of Europe. 1950. Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, 4November. https://treaties.un.org/doc/Publication/UNTS/Volume%20213/volume-213-I-2889-English.pdf.)| false
Dave, Dhaval D., Andrew I.Friedson, KyutaroMatsuzawa, Joseph J.Sabia, and SamuelSafford. 2020. “Black Lives Matter Protests, Social Distancing, and COVID-19.” NBER Working Paper Series, Working Paper 27408. National Bureau of Economic Research. https://www.nber.org/papers/w27408.pdf.
Dave, Dhaval D., Andrew I.Friedson, KyutaroMatsuzawa, Joseph J.Sabia, and SamuelSafford. 2020. “Black Lives Matter Protests, Social Distancing, and COVID-19.” NBER Working Paper Series, Working Paper 27408. National Bureau of Economic Research. https://www.nber.org/papers/w27408.pdf.)| false
Detroit Free Press. 2020. “Vehicle Protests at Michigan Capitol over Gov. Whitmer Stay Home Order.” 15April. https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2020/04/15/michigan-protest-wednesday-live-video/5137207002/.)| false
Feinberg, Myriam, LauraNiada-Avshalom, and BrigitToebes. 2015. “National Security and Public Health: Exceptions to Human Rights?” The International Journal of Human Rights 19(4): 383–387.10.1080/13642987.2015.1044812)| false
Ferguson, John. 2020. “Coronavirus: Hypocrisy Unfettered in March of Stupidity.” The Australian, 11June. https://www.theaustralian.com.au/commentary/coronavirus-black-lives-matter-protest/news-story/32a8b87460e32647047b4cc570f2d39f.)| false
Fordham, Ben. 2020. “NSW Police to Fight Another Black Lives Matter Protest in Court.” 2GB Radio Station (Sydney), 20July. https://www.2gb.com/nsw-police-to-fight-another-black-lives-matter-protest-in-court/.)| false
Gilbert, Keon L., and RashawnRay. 2016. “Why Police Kill Black Males with Impunity: Applying Public Health Critical Race Praxis (PHCRP) to Address the Determinants of Policing Behaviours and ‘Justifiable’ Homicides in the USA.” Journal of Urban Health93 (Suppl 1): 122–140.
Gilbert, Keon L., and RashawnRay. 2016. “Why Police Kill Black Males with Impunity: Applying Public Health Critical Race Praxis (PHCRP) to Address the Determinants of Policing Behaviours and ‘Justifiable’ Homicides in the USA.” Journal of Urban Health 93 (Suppl 1): 122–140.10.1007/s11524-015-0005-x)| false
Gotsis, Tom. 2015. “Protests and the Law in New South Wales.” Briefing Paper No 7, New South Wales Parliamentary Research Service, https://www.parliament.nsw.gov.au/researchpapers/Documents/protests-and-the-law-in-nsw/Protests%20and%20the%20law%20in%20NSW.pdf.)| false
Greer, Steven. 1997. “The Exceptions to Articles 8 to 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights.” Human Rights Files No. 15. https://www.echr.coe.int/LibraryDocs/DG2/HRFILES/DG2-EN-HRFILES-15(1997).pdf.)| false
Harmon, Amy, and RickRojas. 2020. “A Delicate Balance: Weighing Protest against the Risks of the Coronavirus.” New York Times, 7June. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/07/us/Protest-coronavirus-george-floyd.html.)| false
Kontominas, Bellinda. 2020. “NSW Police to Try to Block Sydney Black Lives Matter Protest in Supreme Court Due to Coronavirus Concerns.” ABC News, 21July. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-07-20/nsw-police-to-block-sydney-black-lives-matter-protest-in-court/12474464.)| false
Langton, Marcia. 2020. “Why the Black Lives Matter Protests Must Continue: An Urgent Appeal by Marcia Langton.” The Conversation, 5August. https://theconversation.com/why-the-black-lives-matter-protests-must-continue-an-urgent-appeal-by-marcia-langton-143914.)| false
Lescure, Francois-Xavier, LilaBouadma, DucNguyen, MarionParisey, Paul-HenriWicky, SylvieBehilil, et al. 2020. “Clinical and Virological Data of the First Cases of COVID-19 in Europe: A Case Series.” The Lancet20 (6): 697–706.
Lescure, Francois-Xavier, LilaBouadma, DucNguyen, MarionParisey, Paul-HenriWicky, SylvieBehilil, et al. 2020. “Clinical and Virological Data of the First Cases of COVID-19 in Europe: A Case Series.” The Lancet 20 (6): 697–706.10.1016/S1473-3099(20)30200-0)| false
O'Sullivan, M.2020. “Is Protesting during the Pandemic an ‘Essential’ Right That Should Be Protected?” The Conversation, 21April. https://theconversation.com/is-protesting-during-the-pandemic-an-essential-right-that-should-be-protected-136512.)| false
Ramsden, Pam. 2020. “How the Pandemic Changed Social Media and George Floyd's Death Created a Collective Conscience.” The Conversation, 15June, https://theconversation.com/how-the-pandemic-changed-social-media-and-george-floyds-death-created-a-collective-conscience-140104.)| false
Russo, Thomas A.2020. “How to Protect During a Pandemic and Still Keep Everyone Safe from Coronavirus.” The Conversation, 4June. https://theconversation.com/how-to-protest-during-a-pandemic-and-still-keep-everyone-safe-from-coronavirus-139978.)| false
Schneiders, Ben. 2020. “How Hotel Quarantine Let COVID-19 Out of the Bag in Victoria.” The Age, 3July. https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/how-hotel-quarantine-let-covid-19-out-of-the-bag-in-victoria-20200703-p558og.html.)| false
Scott, Darrell, KareemLanier, and TimDunn. 2020. “Let's Get America Back on Her Feet—Together.” Townhall, 13April. https://townhall.com/columnists/darrellscottkareemlanierandtimdunn/2020/04/13/lets-get-america-back-on-her-feettogether-n2566804.)| false
Varga, Máté. 2020. “The Covid-19 Crisis Shows the Need for Civil Society to Be Stronger Than Ever, Not Only in Hungary.” Civitates. https://civitates-eu.org/the-covid-19-crisis-shows-the-need-for-civil-society-to-be-stronger-than-ever-not-only-in-hungary/.)| false
Visontay, Elias. 2020. “Coronavirus Australia: Judge Refuses Authorisation for Black Lives Matters Protest in Sydney Tomorrow—As It Happened.” The Guardian, 5June. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/live/2020/jun/05/coronavirus-australia-news-updates-covid-19-lancet-study-retracted-travel-bubble-homebuilder-grants-recession-nsw-qld-vic.)| false