Constructing Difference and Imperial Strategy

Contrasting Representations of Irish and Zionist Nationalism in British Political Discourse (1917–1922)

in Historical Reflections/Réflexions Historiques
Maggy Hary Université Paris VII–Denis Diderot

Search for other papers by Maggy Hary in
Current site
Google Scholar
Restricted access


The Irish struggle for independence (1917–1922) coincided with the beginnings of the mandate in Palestine, by which the British government sought to encourage the establishment of a Jewish National Home. Analogies between these two territories regularly surfaced in the papers of British officials and policy makers. Universally perceived as a paradigm of nationalism and insurrection, the Irish precedent colored the British understanding of Palestine. Essentialist representations of national groups such as the Irish or the Jews were also common as the British government lent support to various nationalist movements in order to further strategic objectives during the Great War. However, British attitudes toward Irish nationalism and Zionism varied widely. A careful examination of Arthur James Balfour’s representations of the Irish and Jewish nations reveals that nationalist ideology, far from relying on a coherent and systematic understanding of national groups, shifted depending on Britain’s geopolitical interests.

Contributor Notes

Maggy Hary is Senior Lecturer in British History, Université Paris VII–Denis Diderot.

  • Collapse
  • Expand


All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 1637 1551 207
Full Text Views 17 3 2
PDF Downloads 25 4 0