“Presentism” Versus “Path Dependence”?

Reflections on the Second World War in Russian Textbooks of the 1990s

in Journal of Educational Media, Memory, and Society
View More View Less
  • 1 Director, Nestor-Istoria, Saint Petersburg and Moscow; Scientific Editor, Istoricheskaya Expertiza nestorhistoria2017@gmail.com
Restricted access

Abstract

In the fifteen Russian textbooks of the 1990s examined in this article, the Second World War is subject to three levels of reflection: language, narrative templates, and the representation of contested events. The language used in the textbooks represents an amalgam of Soviet propagandistic clichés and uncritically adopted Western terminology. These textbooks also retain the same “schematic narrative template” of the Second World War, based on references to the expulsion of foreign enemies, found in Soviet textbooks. Significant transformations can be observed only in the representation of events, in which the authors’ harsh criticism of Stalin's crimes comes to the fore. Yet these superficial changes did not alter the basic structures of history learning, which was one of the main reasons why working through the past during the Yeltsin era almost failed.

Contributor Notes

Serguei Ehrlich is the director of the academic publishing house Nestor-Istoria in Saint Petersburg and Moscow, and scientific editor of the journal Istoricheskaya Expertiza (Historical Expertise, https://en.istorex.ru/). Email: nestorhistoria2017@gmail.com

  • Danilov, Alexandr, Rossiya i mir [Russia and the world] (Moscow: Vlados, 1994).

  • Danilov, Alexandr and Liudmila Kosulina, Istoriya Rossii: XX vek [History of Russia: Twentieth century] (Moscow: Prosveshchenie, 1995).

  • Dmitrenko, Vladimir, Vladimir Esakov, and Vladimir Shestakov, Istoriya Otechestva: XX vek [History of the fatherland: Twentieth century] (Moscow: Drofa, 1995).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Doluckij, Igor, Otechestvennaya istoriya: XX vek [Fatherland history: Twentieth century] (Moscow: Mnemozina, 1996).

  • Doluckij, Igor, Otechestvennaya istoriya: XX vek [Fatherland history: Twentieth century] (Moscow: Mnemozina, 1998).

  • Furaev, Victor, Novejshaya istoriya: 1939–1974 [Contemporary history: 1939–1974] (Moscow: Prosveshchenie, 1975).

  • Furaev, Victor, Stepan Volk, Genrih Levin, and Oleg Ostrovskij, Novejshaya istoriya: 1939–1992 [Contemporary history: 1939–1992] (Moscow: Prosveshchenie, 1993).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Kreder, Alexandr, Novejshaya istoriya [Contemporary history] (Moscow: Intepraks, 1994).

  • Kreder, Alexandr,Novejshaya istoriya zarubezhnyh stran: 1914–1997 [Contemporary history of foreign countries: 1914–1917] (Moscow: CGO, 1999).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Levandovskij, Andrei and Yurii Shchetinov, Rossiya v XX veke [Russia in the twentieth century] (Moscow: Prosveshchenie, 1998).

  • Ostrovskij, Valerii, Vitalii Starcev, Boris Starkov, and Gennadii Smirnov, Istoriya Otechestva [History of the fatherland] (Moscow: Prosveshchenie, 1992).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Ostrovskij, Valerii and Alexei Utkin, Istoriya Rossii: XX vek [History of Russia: Twentieth century] (Moscow: Drofa, 1995).

  • Pankratova, Anna, Istoriya SSSR [History of the USSR] (Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe uchebno-pedagogicheskoe izdatel'stvo ministerstva prosveshcheniya RSFSR, 1951).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Pankratova, Anna, Istoriya SSSR [History of the USSR] (Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe uchebno-pedagogicheskoe izdatel'stvo ministerstva prosveshcheniya RSFSR, 1957).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Rodriges, Alexandr, Novejshaya istoriya zarubezhnyh stran: XX vek [Contemporary history of foreign countries: Twentieth century] (Moscow: Vlados, 1998).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Soroko-Cyupa, Oleg, Vladislav Smirnov, Vladimir Poskonin, and Alexandr Stroganov, Mir v pervoj polovine XX veka: 1918–1945 [The world in the first half of the twentieth century: 1918–1945] (Moscow: Prosveshchenie,1994).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Soroko-Cyupa, Oleg, Vladislav Smirnov, Vladimir Poskonin, and Alexandr Stroganov, Mir v XX veke [The world in the twentieth century] (Moscow: Prosveshchenie—AO Moskovskie uchebniki, 1996).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation
  • Zharova, Liudmila and Irina Mishina, Istoriya Otechestva, 1900–1940 [History of the fatherland, 1900–1940] (Moscow: Prosveshchenie, 1992).

    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation

Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 211 211 26
Full Text Views 28 28 2
PDF Downloads 35 35 2