In Defence of Democratic Dirty Hands

in Theoria
Author: Christina Nick1
View More View Less
  • 1 University of Leeds
Restricted access

This paper considers three arguments by David Shugarman and Maureen Ramsay for why dirty hands cannot be democratic. The first argues that it is contradictory, in principle, to use undemocratic means to pursue democratic ends. There is a conceptual connection between means and ends such that getting one’s hands dirty is incompatible with acting in accordance with democratic ends. The second claims that using dirty-handed means, in practice, will undermine democracy more than it promotes it and therefore cannot be justified. The final criticism states that politicians with dirty hands are a sign that politics is no longer meeting the criteria necessary to be called democratic. The paper shows that such rejections of democratic dirty hands are based on misunderstandings of the nature of dirty hands and democratic politics.


A Journal of Social and Political Theory


All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 290 187 35
Full Text Views 30 4 3
PDF Downloads 53 4 2